Scroll to discover home building options, process, and pricing!
Top 9 Custom House Builders in Middleton, WI
Looking for the best custom home builders in Middleton, WI? Compare these highly rated local builders, reviews.
If you’re thinking about building a custom home here in Middleton, there’s a good chance you’ve been dreaming about this for a while.
Maybe it’s a kitchen big enough for Sunday pancakes with the kids, or a mudroom that can finally handle the Wisconsin winters and all the boots, snow pants, and wet mittens that come with them. Maybe it’s just space to breathe a little, inside and out.
But this process isn’t just about materials or floorplans. It’s about trust. It’s about finding someone who will walk with you through each step, listen when something doesn’t feel right, and care about the outcome like it’s their own.
And let’s be real, building here in Middleton comes with its own curveballs. One week it’s warm and muddy, the next we’re shoveling snow off framing lumber.
That’s exactly why we’ve pulled together this guide. It’s a closer look at the most well-reviewed custom builders who are active in Middleton right now. Each one has its own style, strengths, and approach.
Whether your dream home leans sleek and modern or cozy and classic, this list is a starting point to help you find the right fit, someone who understands what this home means to you and what it takes to build it right, here.
1. Conklin Construction – Featured Contractor
At Conklin Construction, we don’t believe in shortcuts unless it’s one we’ve already tested and proven ourselves. We’re a full-service custom home building company here in Middleton, and every home we build is a reflection of the people living in it. That’s why no two Conklin homes look alike.
We start by listening, really listening, to what matters to you. Maybe that’s a big front porch for summer nights, a basement bar for Badger games, or a walk-in shower that doesn’t make you regret leg day. Whatever it is, we work it into the bones of the house, not just the finishes.
What sets us apart?
- Speed without cutting corners: Our tight schedule control and trusted trade teams let us move faster than most without sacrificing an ounce of quality.
- In-house design-build capabilities: That means fewer change orders, smoother communication, and a build that actually reflects what you saw in your head.
- Warranty that means something: We stand by every project and offer a 1-year workmanship guarantee plus guidance well beyond that if you ever have questions.
- Hands-on project management: You’ll know your superintendent, your PM, even our drywall guy if you want. We don’t just build for the neighborhood, we’re part of it.
We also understand the local terrain, zoning, and Middleton building code like the back of our hand. So when it’s time to pull permits or get final inspection, we’ve already done the homework.
We’ve worked jobs off Old Sauk, by Pioneer Park, and everywhere in between. We know the inspectors. We know the rules. And most importantly, we know what homeowners like you expect when you invest in something this big.
What Your Neighbors Say About Conklin Construction
l
Luke Robinson
We built with Ben about two years ago and couldn’t be happier. Ben managed to stay on budget and on time even with all of our changes, accommodating any request we had and actually applying ideas or pictures we had seen.
With being our first time building, Ben and his staff answered our questions and reassured us taking the stress out of the building process. The end result is our beautiful home that we continually get compliments for and couldn’t be happier with.
We definitely recommend Conklin Construction to anyone thinking about building their new home.
j
Jenny Anderson
We worked with Ben and his team to build our first-ever home and they hit it out of the park! We were apprehensive about the entire building process but Ben made it easy.
He walked us through everything, step-by-step. Ben and team kept us up-to-date on progress and worked with us when we found a “big idea” on Pinterest, by making it happen realistically and in budget.
I think working with a team who is open, honest and has great communication is key and that’s exactly what you’ll get when you work with Conklin Construction! Three years later, we still get compliments on our home and the overall quality.
📞 Give us a call at (608) 839-0620 or reach out through our contact page. We’d love to hear what you’re dreaming up.
2. Hart DeNoble Builders, Inc.
Hart DeNoble is a long-standing Middleton builder known for detail, tight site management, and clean finishes, exactly the kind of work that holds up through our freeze-thaw cycles and wind off the prairie.
Their process leans classic “builder-led” with deep trade relationships and a lot of attention to sequencing, which matters when you’re pouring slabs in November or trimming out during a humid June.
They’ve built in the Madison area for decades and it shows in their subs’ rhythm and the way they spec materials that survive Dane County winters: air sealing, drainage planes, and durable exterior claddings.
The team (led by Bryan & Jennie Sipple) treats schedules like a promise, then backs the work with responsive punch-list follow-through. If you’ve walked subdivisions near Waunakee or DeForest, you’ve probably toured one of their homes. In short, big-league craftsmanship with small-town access. You can actually get your builder on the phone.
Unique family team that delivers what they promise. Quality homes with attention to detail
Jerry S
3. Loren Imhoff Homebuilder, Inc.
Loren Imhoff is a Middleton fixture with a design-build flavor and an in-house service arm. They sweat the schedule and keep a close leash on trade coordination, which matters when you’re threading inspections with Middleton’s permitting or juggling custom millwork around the holidays.
Their projects range from new custom homes to significant whole-home remodels, and they’ve been active in Dane County for decades.
Expect practical design help up front, steady communication, and a project team that is used to working through the “real life” stuff: change orders, lead times, and the occasional snow week.
If you want a builder with local roots who can navigate everything from soils in the Town of Middleton to selections that will actually arrive on time, this is a solid, community-minded option.
They guided us through the process step by step and kept things on schedule. The team was responsive whenever we had questions.
Karen M.
4. Rowe Design & Construction, Inc.
Rowe is a family-owned Middleton builder (since 1988) with a “design-forward but practical” streak.
They’re comfortable handling full custom homes and complex remodels, and they communicate like neighbors, which, here, they are. Their “it’s our house but your home” mantra translates into sensible value engineering without stripping character. In real terms: they’ll help you avoid over-spec’ing HVAC or windows for our climate while still hitting the comfort and efficiency you want come February.
Their crews are steady, and their subs are the type you actually see on site, not just in invoices. If you like a hands-on builder who will answer their phone and explain why that soffit detail matters when the west wind hits, Rowe’s your speed.
We are extremely happy with our finished home.
Fritz & Margaret Beh
5. Summit Custom Homes
Summit Custom Homes operates out of Middleton and builds around Dane County (Verona, DeForest, Fitchburg, Madison/Sun Prairie).
Their pitch is owner involvement from start to finish and a focus on craftsmanship over volume.
You’ll see that in their lot selection help and willingness to chase down details most folks gloss over, like drainage around walk-outs or framing tweaks that keep future built-ins square.
They’re comfortable working across communities and can help you weigh subdivision guidelines against Middleton’s design sensibilities so you don’t paint yourself into a corner with covenants. If you want a smaller team that knows your name and doesn’t disappear once drywall goes up, they’re a good fit.
Summit helped us pick the right lot and worked through details without overcomplicating things. The build went smoothly and finished on time.
David & Lisa P.
6. TimberLane Builders, LLC
TimberLane is a boutique custom home builder working throughout Dane County, including Middleton projects.
They’re “no two homes the same” people, offering design services in house, real-estate savvy to help with lots, and a willingness to work inside realistic budgets without sandbagging allowances.
That matters around here, because dirt and utilities can swing costs wildly between the City of Middleton and Town parcels. TimberLane’s value is steady owner engagement and clear trade coordination. They don’t flood the schedule with too many builds at once, which keeps attention tight during framing, MEP rough-ins, and finish. If you want a custom that reads like your home rather than a model series, they’re worth a look.
TimberLane gave us straightforward answers and stayed on budget. The house turned out just like we pictured.
Brian R
7. Jason Thomas Homes LLC
Jason Thomas Homes is a Middleton-based custom home builder focused on original design, tight schedules, and crisp finishes.
They handle the full process, including lot coordination, design guidance, selections, and site management, so you’re not juggling a dozen vendors.
Their portfolio leans modern craftsman and contemporary, but they’ll tailor details to your lifestyle: radiant floors for winter mornings, bigger mudrooms for youth sports chaos, and quiet, well-insulated bedrooms that actually sleep.
It’s a small, hands-on operation. The owner is visible on jobs and responsive during punch, and they build several homes per year around Middleton, Verona, Waunakee, and the west side of Madison. If you like the idea of texting your builder and getting an answer the same day, and then seeing that item show up on tomorrow’s schedule, this is that style of shop.
They also have a consistent track record pulling City of Middleton permits for new custom homes.
The entire construction phase was managed seamlessly.
Samantha R
8. Michael F. Simon Builders, Inc.
Founded in 1893, Michael F. Simon Builders is one of the longest-running custom builders serving Middleton and Dane County. Their team handles true custom homes from design to turn-key with in-house project management, weekly communication, and detailed scheduling.
Expect higher-end building science and energy details, carpentry crews that can execute custom trim packages, and a clean, orderly jobsite (a small thing that tends to signal a well-run project).
They also maintain exclusive lots in Middleton/Waunakee for clients who want a simpler land path. If you care about “forever-home” durability, like straight walls, quiet floors, and mechanicals laid out like someone will service them in 10 years, Simon is built for that.
Their testimonials are full of repeat clients, which aligns with the way they run warranty and service.
Two 5-star reviews:
They took care of every last detail. Simon Builders made our dream home a reality.
Larry
9. Brio Design Homes
Brio is a design-build firm, which means your architect, interior designer, and builder sync under one roof. That is useful when you’re weighing that bigger window wall against budget and HVAC.
Their portfolio shows strong fit-and-finish, smart cabinet layouts, and site-responsive design (think lake wind, western sun, snow loads, and drift management in a Wisconsin winter). Brio’s process page and “collections” make style exploration easy, but they still start with your life: pets, hobbies, and how you move through a Sunday morning.
If you want a home that doesn’t look like anyone else’s, and don’t want to play referee between separate designer and builder, Brio is worth short-listing.
They were a dream to work with from start to finish.
Dale & Jane
10. Martinson Building
Martinson Building, located near McFarland, WI, specializes in custom home construction and remodeling services. With a focus on quality craftsmanship and personalized service, they work closely with clients to bring their vision to life.
Martinson Building is known for their attention to detail and commitment to delivering high-quality homes that meet the unique needs of each homeowner.
Martinson Building constructed our custom home, and we couldn’t be happier. Their team was professional, and the quality of work is top-notch.
David H.
Your Dream Home Deserves More Than a Guess
Building a custom home is exciting, no question. But it is also filled with decisions, second-guesses, and surprise weather patterns (hello, snowstorms).
That is why choosing a builder in Middleton means looking beyond the polished photos, toward the people who will actually be there when questions come up, who keep their word, and who take the time to do things right.
All the builders in our list have something to offer. They are skilled, established, and come with plenty of 5-star praise to back them up. But here’s the deal, when it comes to building a home that is deeply personal, you want a team who treats your vision like their own.
At Conklin Construction, we take pride in building custom homes that feel like they truly belong to you and to this community. From that first conversation to the final walkthrough, we’re right there with you, answering questions, solving problems, and making sure every detail feels just right.
Call us at (608) 839-0620 or message us here to start the conversation. We would be glad to hear what you’re planning and help you bring it to life.